{ "comparisonId": "e1c7afaf-93af-4d9c-baea-350c4f28811b", "engineVersion": "process-des-2.7.0", "seeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261027, 20261028 ], "n": 20, "windowSeconds": 21600, "warmupSeconds": 0, "sharedInputs": { "arrivals": true, "window": true, "seed": true, "runs": true }, "completedAllSeeds": true, "totalArrivedAndCompletedEachOption": 867, "unfinishedPatients": { "A": 0, "B": 0 }, "blockedPatients": { "A": 0, "B": 0 }, "eventLimits": 0, "arrivalOrJobLimits": 0, "coreMeasures": [ { "id": "run.arrived", "scope": "run", "ref": null, "unit": "count", "baseline": 43.35, "candidate": 43.35, "delta": 0, "paired": { "min": 0, "mean": 0, "max": 0, "stdev": 0, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "withinNoise": true } }, { "id": "run.completed", "scope": "run", "ref": null, "unit": "count", "baseline": 43.35, "candidate": 43.35, "delta": 0, "paired": { "min": 0, "mean": 0, "max": 0, "stdev": 0, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "withinNoise": true } }, { "id": "run.blocked", "scope": "run", "ref": null, "unit": "count", "baseline": 0, "candidate": 0, "delta": 0, "paired": { "min": 0, "mean": 0, "max": 0, "stdev": 0, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": 0, "high": 0, "withinNoise": true } }, { "id": "run.wait.mean", "scope": "run", "ref": null, "unit": "s", "baseline": 1902.16270762074, "candidate": 1922.536314288935, "delta": 20.373606668194753, "paired": { "min": -10.89197803235561, "mean": 20.373606668194753, "max": 63.498071766449584, "stdev": 21.660673520042266, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": 9.972863208741476, "high": 30.77435012764803, "withinNoise": false } }, { "id": "run.cycle.mean", "scope": "run", "ref": null, "unit": "s", "baseline": 2854.2932563953214, "candidate": 2857.2482302390945, "delta": 2.954973843772689, "paired": { "min": -28.519320608077805, "mean": 2.954973843772689, "max": 45.894664951896175, "stdev": 21.678906887643194, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": -7.454524679489832, "high": 13.364472367035209, "withinNoise": true } }, { "id": "run.distance.total", "scope": "run", "ref": null, "unit": "m", "baseline": 4101.452453229362, "candidate": 3345.4639028562538, "delta": -755.9885503731073, "paired": { "min": -1152.975019527239, "mean": -755.9885503731073, "max": -462.9814242453499, "stdev": 138.89427602954615, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": -822.6810164052984, "high": -689.2960843409162, "withinNoise": false } }, { "id": "run.completion.all", "scope": "run", "ref": null, "unit": "s", "baseline": 11868.578605942463, "candidate": 11881.274171057164, "delta": 12.695565114701731, "paired": { "min": -236.3599985205874, "mean": 12.695565114701731, "max": 110.84655126680991, "stdev": 80.82716688878544, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": -26.114983716424057, "high": 51.506113945827515, "withinNoise": true } } ], "stepWaits": [ { "id": "process.time.mean", "scope": "process", "ref": "checkin-wait", "unit": "s", "baseline": 18.705477380671418, "candidate": 122.93101026935054, "delta": 104.22553288867907, "paired": { "min": 29.377863259528482, "mean": 104.22553288867907, "max": 313.4945486397693, "stdev": 68.53884382038154, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": 71.31543289000035, "high": 137.1356328873578, "withinNoise": false }, "coverage": { "A": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261027, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [], "n": 20 }, "B": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261027, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [], "n": 20 } } }, { "id": "process.time.mean", "scope": "process", "ref": "payment-wait", "unit": "s", "baseline": 9.484422133528332, "candidate": 11.312732338517694, "delta": 1.8283102049893614, "paired": { "min": -14.114244487233348, "mean": 1.8283102049893614, "max": 11.575134608166447, "stdev": 5.286788476425544, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": -0.7102318498926252, "high": 4.366852259871348, "withinNoise": true }, "coverage": { "A": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261027, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [], "n": 20 }, "B": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261027, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [], "n": 20 } } }, { "id": "process.time.mean", "scope": "process", "ref": "doctor-wait", "unit": "s", "baseline": 1698.3705860772639, "candidate": 1619.499102056592, "delta": -78.8714840206718, "paired": { "min": -266.0794771293372, "mean": -78.8714840206718, "max": 0.647188735993609, "stdev": 64.70495077623296, "n": 20 }, "interval": { "low": -109.94067459581501, "high": -47.80229344552859, "withinNoise": false }, "coverage": { "A": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261027, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [], "n": 20 }, "B": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261027, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [], "n": 20 } } }, { "id": "process.time.mean", "scope": "process", "ref": "return-doctor-wait", "unit": "s", "baseline": 1757.5501521727665, "candidate": 1682.566467774842, "delta": null, "paired": null, "reason": "missing_value", "coverage": { "A": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [ 20261027 ], "n": 19 }, "B": { "validSeeds": [ 20261009, 20261010, 20261011, 20261012, 20261013, 20261014, 20261015, 20261016, 20261017, 20261018, 20261019, 20261020, 20261021, 20261022, 20261023, 20261024, 20261025, 20261026, 20261028 ], "missingSeeds": [ 20261027 ], "n": 19 } } } ], "resourceUtilization": [ { "id": "receptionists", "A": 0.21275376189386913, "B": null, "delta": null, "interval": null, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 2, "capacityB": null }, { "id": "checkin-receptionist", "A": null, "B": 0.24430847037628864, "delta": null, "interval": null, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": null, "capacityB": 1 }, { "id": "payment-receptionist", "A": null, "B": 0.18119905341144965, "delta": null, "interval": null, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": null, "capacityB": 1 }, { "id": "doctors", "A": 0.5056519563426073, "B": 0.5056665668460949, "delta": 0.00001461050348769144, "interval": { "low": -0.00003782841192082131, "high": 0.00006704941889620418, "withinNoise": true }, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 2, "capacityB": 2 }, { "id": "nurses", "A": 0.12189310230216592, "B": 0.12189310230216592, "delta": 1.734723475976807e-18, "interval": { "low": -7.563108739826037e-18, "high": 1.1032555691779651e-17, "withinNoise": true }, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 2, "capacityB": 2 }, { "id": "radiographer", "A": 0.08711011776053709, "B": 0.08711011776053709, "delta": -7.979727989493312e-18, "interval": { "low": -2.5333247207772515e-17, "high": 9.373791228785891e-18, "withinNoise": true }, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 1, "capacityB": 1 }, { "id": "room1", "A": 0.2649691770995189, "B": 0.2654073935533545, "delta": 0.0004382164538356464, "interval": { "low": -0.00740178014633802, "high": 0.008278213054009312, "withinNoise": true }, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 1, "capacityB": 1 }, { "id": "room2", "A": 0.25653721914499594, "B": 0.25822529104225106, "delta": 0.0016880718972552195, "interval": { "low": -0.004849517759286593, "high": 0.008225661553797033, "withinNoise": true }, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 1, "capacityB": 1 }, { "id": "room3", "A": 0.2446198412868495, "B": 0.24455027088001763, "delta": -0.00006957040683180788, "interval": { "low": -0.00704645955788991, "high": 0.006907318744226295, "withinNoise": true }, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 1, "capacityB": 1 }, { "id": "room4", "A": 0.24517767515385, "B": 0.24315017821656623, "delta": -0.002027496937283714, "interval": { "low": -0.010383345712656346, "high": 0.006328351838088917, "withinNoise": true }, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "capacityA": 1, "capacityB": 1 } ], "distancePerPatient": { "A": { "n": 20, "min": 88.59869180876629, "mean": 94.76209854351802, "max": 100.0801726351135 }, "B": { "n": 20, "min": 71.1103708708432, "mean": 77.34346571909627, "max": 83.10824957446907 }, "pairedDifference": { "n": 20, "mean": -17.418632824421742, "low": -17.549325115465606, "high": -17.287940533377878, "withinNoise": false } }, "shortages": { "A": { "peak": { "n": 20, "min": 6, "mean": 14.3, "max": 32 }, "shortageAtPeak": { "n": 20, "min": 0, "mean": 0.75, "max": 12 }, "seedsAbove20": [ 20261010, 20261013, 20261015 ], "seedsWithShortage": 3, "denominatorSeeds": 20 }, "B": { "peak": { "n": 20, "min": 6, "mean": 13.75, "max": 29 }, "shortageAtPeak": { "n": 20, "min": 0, "mean": 0.55, "max": 9 }, "seedsAbove20": [ 20261010, 20261013, 20261015 ], "seedsWithShortage": 3, "denominatorSeeds": 20 }, "pairedDifference": { "n": 20, "mean": -0.2, "low": -0.5256651929432077, "high": 0.12566519294320766, "withinNoise": true } }, "sampledDuration": { "A": { "seed": 20261009, "sampledSecondsAbove20": 0, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "sampleIntervalSeconds": 180, "method": "Left endpoint occupancy held until the next native 180-second sample. First seed only; may miss short intervals. Not exact seat-unavailable seconds or a mean over twenty seeds." }, "B": { "seed": 20261009, "sampledSecondsAbove20": 0, "denominatorSeconds": 21600, "sampleIntervalSeconds": 180, "method": "Left endpoint occupancy held until the next native 180-second sample. First seed only; may miss short intervals. Not exact seat-unavailable seconds or a mean over twenty seeds." } }, "matchedFirstSeedPatients": 46, "matchedFirstSeedRandomServiceDraws": 155, "fullPrecisionReplicatesMatchComparisonMeans": true, "perRunReplySixSignificantDigitsMatchNative": true, "waitingTraceControls": { "A": { "seed": 20261009, "jobId": "morning-arrivals:3", "wait": { "type": "wait", "endSeconds": 738.1725824819496, "resourceId": "doctors", "units": 1, "stepIndex": 0, "startSeconds": 415.7714963267843, "completed": true, "processId": "doctor-wait" }, "nextGoto": { "type": "goto", "endSeconds": 754.4762012617031, "floorId": "floor-1", "distanceMeters": 16.30361877975345, "stepIndex": 1, "startSeconds": 738.1725824819496, "completed": true, "processId": "consult3" }, "waitingPoint": { "x": 4.225, "z": 13.025 }, "matchingTracePoints": [ { "x": 4.225000000000001, "z": 13.025, "t": 415.7714963267843 }, { "x": 4.225, "z": 13.025, "t": 738.1725824819496 }, { "x": 4.225, "z": 13.025, "t": 1170.7053032114554 } ] }, "B": { "seed": 20261009, "jobId": "morning-arrivals:3", "wait": { "type": "wait", "endSeconds": 737.1393728804928, "resourceId": "doctors", "units": 1, "stepIndex": 0, "startSeconds": 520.0383691127303, "completed": true, "processId": "doctor-wait" }, "nextGoto": { "type": "goto", "endSeconds": 753.4429916602463, "floorId": "floor-1", "distanceMeters": 16.30361877975345, "stepIndex": 1, "startSeconds": 737.1393728804928, "completed": true, "processId": "consult3" }, "waitingPoint": { "x": 4.225, "z": 13.025 }, "matchingTracePoints": [ { "x": 4.225000000000001, "z": 13.025, "t": 520.0383691127303 }, { "x": 4.225, "z": 13.025, "t": 737.1393728804928 }, { "x": 4.225, "z": 13.025, "t": 1169.6720936099987 } ] } }, "interpretation": "B shortens patient movement but increases mean observed patient wait; total cycle-time difference is not established. Reception allocation and window geometry changed together, so no isolated path-only effect or optimality is claimed.", "limits": "Circular patient route model with overlapping logical queue positions; room zones and representative treatment point, not seat/bed assignment. Static staff reach only. No clinical safety, wheelchair turning, shielding, legal compliance or field accuracy validation. Null measures, including review-only steps in seeds without imaging, remain missing.", "version": 2, "synthetic": true, "article": "clinic-flow-comparison", "authoringSource": "45f6a99df4a50d2774201f94749edc37c44b5bde", "geometry": { "widthMetres": 21, "depthMetres": 15, "areaSquareMetres": 315, "consultationRooms": 4, "staffEachOption": 7, "chairs": 20, "assumedWheelchairBays": 2, "findingsA": 0, "findingsB": 0, "excludedGapsEachOption": 4, "reachableTargetsA": 49, "reachableTargetsB": 51, "patientRadiiMetres": [ 0.3, 0.45 ], "staffRadiusMetres": 0.3, "clearanceMetres": 0.9, "taggedPassageMetres": 1.5, "assumedOperatingClearancesMetres": { "consultationCouchesWest": 0.95, "leftTreatmentEast": 1.2, "rightTreatmentWest": 1.24, "xraySouth": 1.75 } }, "separateSessionReopen": { "eachNamedSaveRevision": 3, "matched": [ "building", "scenarios", "designOptions", "processOptions", "comparison", "packedResults", "reports" ], "allFourHtmlReexportsByteIdentical": true, "recalculationOnReopen": false }, "acceptance": { "staticMcpDrawings": true, "currentBrowser3D2D": true, "desktop": true, "desktop390": false, "actualPdf": true, "sourceCommit": "674a7ccea54604c99ea4f7af8b4dbe176ce2fda6", "localOnly": true, "browser": "Chrome FrontMind (front-mind.com)", "viewport": { "widthCssPx": 1261, "heightCssPx": 805, "devicePixelRatio": 2, "narrow390Verified": false }, "namedBrowserSaveReopen": { "options": [ "A", "B" ], "savedVersionEach": 1, "protectedFieldCountEach": 16, "allProtectedFieldsMatchFormalAndSaved": true, "savedViewPreserved": true, "originalFilesUnchanged": true, "recalculation": false }, "pdf": { "files": 4, "pages": 24, "authoredPages": 6, "evidencePages": 18, "paper": { "A3Landscape": 4, "A4Portrait": 20 }, "allPagesVisuallyChecked": true, "independentReview": "PASS", "rendererVersion": "laydyne-report-svg-1.0.0", "rasterDpi": 150, "selectableText": false, "physicalPrintingVerified": false }, "unverified": [ "Measured 390px viewport", "UI project JSON download and file-chooser import", "Production browser acceptance" ], "meaning": "Both options passed local desktop 3D/2D, named save and UI-list reopen. All four actual Studio PDFs passed 24-page visual and independent review. A requested 390px override did not change the measured 1261px width; narrow acceptance remains incomplete." }, "access": "Free viewing and saved-result replay; Pro recalculation.", "artifacts": [ { "file": "files/A-current.laydyne.json", "bytes": 752796, "sha256": "f74965e87d218ca2309a329b11160b28b476435fa02613d4e147d1de75109bf1" }, { "file": "files/A-decision.html", "bytes": 819253, "sha256": "5764e5f202740f01087644353725df5f139c0892cb87b607d5c0de54a3287d45" }, { "file": "files/A-submission.html", "bytes": 2775061, "sha256": "1b21fdd1475dee3b72271ae7e0fb360cecefe2d16d088fc66f1051ddd804debe" }, { "file": "files/B-current.laydyne.json", "bytes": 735342, "sha256": "cc0e7da686a06f9e5b9bbc39a6560b3198dbeec0d1f85b2524735a7e90b99978" }, { "file": "files/B-decision.html", "bytes": 820154, "sha256": "7ca66592487ca06dd3cc3fb73f7a9b2ca9a7d805117b57f0edc26323cad9941e" }, { "file": "files/B-submission.html", "bytes": 2775731, "sha256": "6f12c313b9cb54040ceace7323ec751436d74a3982da3630efe0eaa4ecfbd4ed" }, { "file": "files/comparison.json", "bytes": 147456, "sha256": "986ab37d10a0d2bc8f840ca959e70f2fafc6e02f9fcdefa13f343f6c8498954a" }, { "file": "files/per-seed.csv", "bytes": 4796, "sha256": "0fbcd0281fd53eb01fba94a05212a2603616a34c4653e03e899b68bcd5076277" }, { "file": "images/A-plan.svg", "bytes": 64225, "sha256": "444d01ee1eda0b6c94842c7644030f0dd84db97ba1b05cb79b94334aaf439ebd" }, { "file": "images/B-plan.svg", "bytes": 64282, "sha256": "f0bc5b514f6abf1cda171d604253a45f540023d72be81c749bce9a8023d45316" }, { "file": "files/A-decision.pdf", "bytes": 1076414, "sha256": "6c92684860807f4b5d51ee50066f473123c2b0a55371c9478b775415261b27db" }, { "file": "files/A-submission.pdf", "bytes": 2284969, "sha256": "e54ab4d326ae27d9ba045ab6ca10984ed957064e0b9a47a5ec683e1e2e35cc88" }, { "file": "files/B-decision.pdf", "bytes": 1068443, "sha256": "5ad2ca0af9675eea384f0b5dbd797e050b6118a428524b8d23aa7a59b87e1cb4" }, { "file": "files/B-submission.pdf", "bytes": 2273144, "sha256": "c32d8c0b02aae139a2d2d0879b025f231ddb6c7039c55d08938914c45f679a33" }, { "file": "images/A-pc-3d.jpg", "bytes": 80490, "sha256": "5e54b396d80bec65963ecf696007c632a5047a68ec3aa102960b48064fecfbbb" }, { "file": "images/A-pc-2d.jpg", "bytes": 115237, "sha256": "57dfb438eb061f1a536443eb1c05b194f2a021af6bdf14ab42ab135a66188e7e" }, { "file": "images/B-pc-3d.jpg", "bytes": 78155, "sha256": "61bdf206efc90da06d504430558a7ac56df9b74c61adde3d52808e51df856d96" }, { "file": "images/B-pc-2d.jpg", "bytes": 114320, "sha256": "7ce6aea7b277073cedf3548ac691be3162fd91288b7261e1c9fe8379228d7614" } ], "reportHtmlPages": { "A": { "decision": { "documentId": "UC-MED-A-decision", "documentRevision": 3, "authored": { "count": 1, "paper": "A4 portrait" }, "evidence": { "count": 3, "paper": "A4 portrait" }, "total": 4 }, "submission": { "documentId": "UC-MED-A-submission", "documentRevision": 2, "authored": { "count": 2, "paper": "A3 landscape" }, "evidence": { "count": 6, "paper": "A4 portrait" }, "total": 8 } }, "B": { "decision": { "documentId": "UC-MED-B-decision", "documentRevision": 1, "authored": { "count": 1, "paper": "A4 portrait" }, "evidence": { "count": 3, "paper": "A4 portrait" }, "total": 4 }, "submission": { "documentId": "UC-MED-B-submission", "documentRevision": 2, "authored": { "count": 2, "paper": "A3 landscape" }, "evidence": { "count": 6, "paper": "A4 portrait" }, "total": 8 } }, "actualPdfVerified": true } }