{ "method": "For each unchanged option, run the same twenty seeds 20261006..20261025 individually. Count only completed jobs from arrivals finished-A, finished-B or finished-C with completedAtSeconds within [1800,10800], divide by 2.5 hours. All job records were checked against arrived counts and total completions in the observation. Aggregate throughput reproduced every saved study run for A, B and Search best; the ceiling candidate reproduced its searched aggregate mean. No process timing, demand or resource rule changed.", "engineVersion": "process-des-2.7.0", "seed": 20261006, "runs": 20, "horizonSeconds": 10800, "warmupSeconds": 1800, "options": [ { "name": "Option A", "robots": 4, "spaceHash": "fnv1a-1e7fd00e", "records": [ { "seed": 20261006, "customerOrdersCompleted": 248, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 99.2, "aggregateThroughput": 102, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261007, "customerOrdersCompleted": 243, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 97.2, "aggregateThroughput": 100, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261008, "customerOrdersCompleted": 254, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 101.6, "aggregateThroughput": 104.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261009, "customerOrdersCompleted": 248, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 99.2, "aggregateThroughput": 102, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261010, "customerOrdersCompleted": 250, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 100, "aggregateThroughput": 102.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261011, "customerOrdersCompleted": 251, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 100.4, "aggregateThroughput": 103.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261012, "customerOrdersCompleted": 249, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 99.6, "aggregateThroughput": 102.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261013, "customerOrdersCompleted": 244, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 97.6, "aggregateThroughput": 100.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261014, "customerOrdersCompleted": 245, "chargeJobsCompleted": 6, "orderThroughput": 98, "aggregateThroughput": 100.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261015, "customerOrdersCompleted": 252, "chargeJobsCompleted": 6, "orderThroughput": 100.8, "aggregateThroughput": 103.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261016, "customerOrdersCompleted": 251, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 100.4, "aggregateThroughput": 103.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261017, "customerOrdersCompleted": 252, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 100.8, "aggregateThroughput": 103.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261018, "customerOrdersCompleted": 249, "chargeJobsCompleted": 6, "orderThroughput": 99.6, "aggregateThroughput": 102, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261019, "customerOrdersCompleted": 251, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 100.4, "aggregateThroughput": 103.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261020, "customerOrdersCompleted": 249, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 99.6, "aggregateThroughput": 102.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261021, "customerOrdersCompleted": 243, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 97.2, "aggregateThroughput": 100, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261022, "customerOrdersCompleted": 251, "chargeJobsCompleted": 6, "orderThroughput": 100.4, "aggregateThroughput": 102.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261023, "customerOrdersCompleted": 251, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 100.4, "aggregateThroughput": 103.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261024, "customerOrdersCompleted": 249, "chargeJobsCompleted": 6, "orderThroughput": 99.6, "aggregateThroughput": 102, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261025, "customerOrdersCompleted": 254, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 101.6, "aggregateThroughput": 104.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 } ], "summary": { "n": 20, "mean": 99.67999999999999, "low": 99.06779161552535, "high": 100.29220838447463, "aggregateMean": 102.38000000000001, "meanChargingJobsPerHour": 2.699999999999999 } }, { "name": "Option B", "robots": 3, "spaceHash": "fnv1a-9909287b", "records": [ { "seed": 20261006, "customerOrdersCompleted": 272, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 108.8, "aggregateThroughput": 112, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261007, "customerOrdersCompleted": 246, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 98.4, "aggregateThroughput": 101.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261008, "customerOrdersCompleted": 277, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 110.8, "aggregateThroughput": 114, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261009, "customerOrdersCompleted": 248, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 99.2, "aggregateThroughput": 102, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261010, "customerOrdersCompleted": 278, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 111.2, "aggregateThroughput": 114.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261011, "customerOrdersCompleted": 263, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 105.2, "aggregateThroughput": 108, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261012, "customerOrdersCompleted": 270, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 108, "aggregateThroughput": 111.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261013, "customerOrdersCompleted": 250, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 100, "aggregateThroughput": 103.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261014, "customerOrdersCompleted": 284, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 113.6, "aggregateThroughput": 116.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261015, "customerOrdersCompleted": 288, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 115.2, "aggregateThroughput": 118.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261016, "customerOrdersCompleted": 283, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 113.2, "aggregateThroughput": 116.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261017, "customerOrdersCompleted": 268, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 107.2, "aggregateThroughput": 110.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261018, "customerOrdersCompleted": 287, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 114.8, "aggregateThroughput": 118, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261019, "customerOrdersCompleted": 271, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 108.4, "aggregateThroughput": 111.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261020, "customerOrdersCompleted": 265, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 106, "aggregateThroughput": 109.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261021, "customerOrdersCompleted": 266, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 106.4, "aggregateThroughput": 109.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261022, "customerOrdersCompleted": 289, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 115.6, "aggregateThroughput": 118.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261023, "customerOrdersCompleted": 279, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 111.6, "aggregateThroughput": 114.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261024, "customerOrdersCompleted": 292, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 116.8, "aggregateThroughput": 119.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261025, "customerOrdersCompleted": 273, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 109.2, "aggregateThroughput": 112.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 } ], "summary": { "n": 20, "mean": 108.97999999999999, "low": 106.45194855544099, "high": 111.50805144455899, "aggregateMean": 112.06000000000002, "meanChargingJobsPerHour": 3.080000000000001 } }, { "name": "Search best (proposal completion metric)", "robots": 3, "spaceHash": "fnv1a-79618823", "records": [ { "seed": 20261006, "customerOrdersCompleted": 274, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 109.6, "aggregateThroughput": 112.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261007, "customerOrdersCompleted": 247, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 98.8, "aggregateThroughput": 101.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261008, "customerOrdersCompleted": 277, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 110.8, "aggregateThroughput": 114, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261009, "customerOrdersCompleted": 249, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 99.6, "aggregateThroughput": 102.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261010, "customerOrdersCompleted": 277, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 110.8, "aggregateThroughput": 114, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261011, "customerOrdersCompleted": 266, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 106.4, "aggregateThroughput": 109.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261012, "customerOrdersCompleted": 271, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 108.4, "aggregateThroughput": 111.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261013, "customerOrdersCompleted": 252, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 100.8, "aggregateThroughput": 104, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261014, "customerOrdersCompleted": 287, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 114.8, "aggregateThroughput": 117.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261015, "customerOrdersCompleted": 289, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 115.6, "aggregateThroughput": 118.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261016, "customerOrdersCompleted": 283, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 113.2, "aggregateThroughput": 116.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261017, "customerOrdersCompleted": 267, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 106.8, "aggregateThroughput": 110, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261018, "customerOrdersCompleted": 287, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 114.8, "aggregateThroughput": 118, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261019, "customerOrdersCompleted": 271, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 108.4, "aggregateThroughput": 111.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261020, "customerOrdersCompleted": 265, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 106, "aggregateThroughput": 109.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261021, "customerOrdersCompleted": 267, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 106.8, "aggregateThroughput": 109.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261022, "customerOrdersCompleted": 289, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 115.6, "aggregateThroughput": 118.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261023, "customerOrdersCompleted": 279, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 111.6, "aggregateThroughput": 114.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261024, "customerOrdersCompleted": 295, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 118, "aggregateThroughput": 121.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261025, "customerOrdersCompleted": 274, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 109.6, "aggregateThroughput": 112.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 } ], "summary": { "n": 20, "mean": 109.31999999999996, "low": 106.80026150163822, "high": 111.83973849836171, "meanChargingJobsPerHour": 3.100000000000001 } }, { "name": "Highest aggregate-throughput candidate", "robots": 5, "benchCentre": { "x": 19, "z": 27.5 }, "pitch": 4, "spaceHash": "fnv1a-c2372dee", "records": [ { "seed": 20261006, "customerOrdersCompleted": 273, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 109.2, "aggregateThroughput": 112.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261007, "customerOrdersCompleted": 247, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 98.8, "aggregateThroughput": 101.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261008, "customerOrdersCompleted": 276, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 110.4, "aggregateThroughput": 113.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261009, "customerOrdersCompleted": 249, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 99.6, "aggregateThroughput": 102.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261010, "customerOrdersCompleted": 277, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 110.8, "aggregateThroughput": 114, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261011, "customerOrdersCompleted": 266, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 106.4, "aggregateThroughput": 109.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261012, "customerOrdersCompleted": 272, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 108.8, "aggregateThroughput": 112, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261013, "customerOrdersCompleted": 253, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 101.2, "aggregateThroughput": 104.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261014, "customerOrdersCompleted": 290, "chargeJobsCompleted": 7, "orderThroughput": 116, "aggregateThroughput": 118.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261015, "customerOrdersCompleted": 289, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 115.6, "aggregateThroughput": 118.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261016, "customerOrdersCompleted": 283, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 113.2, "aggregateThroughput": 116.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261017, "customerOrdersCompleted": 267, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 106.8, "aggregateThroughput": 110, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261018, "customerOrdersCompleted": 286, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 114.4, "aggregateThroughput": 117.6, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261019, "customerOrdersCompleted": 273, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 109.2, "aggregateThroughput": 112.4, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261020, "customerOrdersCompleted": 265, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 106, "aggregateThroughput": 109.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261021, "customerOrdersCompleted": 267, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 106.8, "aggregateThroughput": 110, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261022, "customerOrdersCompleted": 292, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 116.8, "aggregateThroughput": 120, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261023, "customerOrdersCompleted": 279, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 111.6, "aggregateThroughput": 114.8, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261024, "customerOrdersCompleted": 297, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 118.8, "aggregateThroughput": 122, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 }, { "seed": 20261025, "customerOrdersCompleted": 275, "chargeJobsCompleted": 8, "orderThroughput": 110, "aggregateThroughput": 113.2, "from": 1800, "until": 10800 } ], "summary": { "n": 20, "mean": 109.52000000000001, "low": 106.92844942664985, "high": 112.11155057335017, "aggregateMean": 112.64000000000001, "meanChargingJobsPerHour": 3.1200000000000014 } } ], "pairedCustomerOrderDifferences": { "bestMinusA": { "n": 20, "mean": 9.639999999999997, "low": 7.323304307723921, "high": 11.956695692276073, "withinNoise": false }, "bestMinusB": { "n": 20, "mean": 0.33999999999999775, "low": 0.11052230568206645, "high": 0.569477694317929, "withinNoise": false } }, "intervalMethod": "Mean ± 2.093 × sample standard deviation / sqrt(20), matching Laydyne's t-based 95% interval.", "limitation": "The native search's run.throughput.per_hour includes charging-proxy jobs. The three-robot Search best is the leader under the proposal's aggregate completion criterion; it is not a validated feasible solution of the 110 customer-order/h mean criterion. The separate ceiling search also used aggregate throughput. The audits do not prove that no other candidate could pass an order-only criterion.", "restoredDesignOption": "cv-customer-layout", "restoredSpaceHash": "fnv1a-1e7fd00e" }